<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src="https://q.quora.com/_/ad/0198544fd2514a0fb72f9b9f75905f7f/pixel?tag=ViewContent&amp;noscript=1">
Team Operations
Team Communications
Payroll NEW
Featured Reads
For our customers: Product roadmap sneak peek
Hourly Wage Index
Discover how your pay practices stack up against other regions, positions, and industries. 
Understanding the I-9 Form

Understanding the I-9 Form

Understanding the I-9 form can feel like trying to decipher a foreign language. There is no need to panic because we're here to help. The I-9 form is your ticket to building a rock-solid team and it's all about verifying an employee's identity and work authorization in the U.S. Our guide covers completion, verification, and storage for hourly employers that would help boost compliance immediately. 

Understanding the Purpose of the I-9 Form

The Form I-9 is a crucial document in the hiring process, designed to ensure compliance with U.S. immigration laws. Its main objective is to verify that every new hire is legally authorized to work in America. Within three days of being hired, employees must present documents that prove their identity.

By requiring the completion of the Form I-9, companies not only follow legal employment practices but also help prevent the employment of unauthorized workers.

Who Needs to Complete the I-9 Form?

All employers in the US must ensure that all new employees complete their Form I-9 documentation upon hiring, regardless of citizenship. However, independent contractors or sporadic domestic help are exempt from this requirement.

It is crucial for companies to understand their responsibilities and avoid confusion between different categories of workers.

Completing the I-9 Form: A Three-Step Guide

Navigating the Form I-9 process may seem complex, but it's actually a simple three-step journey. Let's break down these steps to make your employee cycle I-9 compliance viewpoint clearer and easier.

1. Employee Information and Attestation

The first part of this adventure involves filling out personal details by the employees themselves. This is where the form collects identifying information like full name, address, date of birth, etc., all crucial for employment eligibility confirmation.

In addition to their personal data collection, they must also attest to their citizenship status - whether they are a United States citizen or not, lawful permanent residents, or aliens authorized to work in the U.S. until certain dates. Here, you can find detailed instructions on how an older Form I-9 should be correctly filled out with respect to different statuses.

2. Examining Documentation for Verification

Moving onto step two. Here, employers play detective as they examine each person's Form I-9 documentation closely, ensuring that the documents provided by employees serve as valid proof of identity and employment authorization.

This requires keen observation skills so that authenticity isn't compromised at any point during the completion of forms. You're dealing with important legal procedures here; hence, following guidelines carefully will keep you from stepping into potential pitfalls.

3. Re-verification and Rehire Scenarios

Last but certainly not least, we have our third stage  with is re-verification & re-hires. In cases when an employee's document expires or if he/she gets re-hired within 36 months since the original completion date, then the updated Form I-9 procedure comes into play, which might include remote verification too.

This doesn't apply to U.S. citizens nor individuals who initially presented receipts instead of actual documents according to USCIS alternative procedure rules. So breathe easy knowing there are exceptions to every rule.

Key Takeaway: 

Mastering the I-9 form is a cinch with our three-step guide. Employees fill out personal details and attest to their citizenship status, employers verify document authenticity, and then comes re-verification for rehires or expired documents. Keep your wits about you to avoid legal pitfalls.

Document Verification Requirements

The Form I-9 process isn't as daunting as it seems and with the right information, you can navigate through this important part of onboarding with ease. The key to a smooth experience lies in understanding and following document verification requirements.

Recognizing Acceptable Documents for Form I-9

To make your journey towards completing an employee's Form I-9 less bumpy, let's first identify what documents are acceptable. According to United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS), these include:

  • A U.S. Passport or U.S. Passport Card
  • A Permanent Resident Card or Green Card
  • An Employment Authorization Document that contains a photograph or
  • If none of the above is available - one document from List B (proving identity) and another from List C (proving employment authorization)

Careful Examination: Your Key To Compliance

Now it's time to examine each person's Form I-9 documentation meticulously. No photocopies allowed. All presented documents must appear genuine upon physical examination and relate directly to the individual presenting them.

Tackling Remote Form I-9 Verification Process

In today's digital world where remote hiring has become commonplace, there may be instances when you need to conduct verifications electronically via remote Form I-9 verification process. USCIS guidelines walk us through how we can maintain compliance while conducting such procedures remotely.

Retaining and Storing I-9 Forms

The importance of retaining and storing Form I-9s correctly cannot be overstated. These forms must be kept safe, readily available for inspection, but protected from unauthorized access.

Understanding the Retention Rules

You might ask, "How long should we retain I-9 forms properly?" The United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) has clear guidelines on this matter. You are required to keep a person's Form I-9 either three years after their hiring date or one year post-employment termination whichever is later.

This means if an employee works less than three years with you, it's important to store their completed form until at least a year following their departure. For those who stay longer than that period, hold onto these documents for no less than three years since they started working with your company.

Safeguarding Completed I-9 Forms

Your options when it comes to storage include keeping physical copies in secure locations or digitally saving them electronically each method having its own merits based on your organizational needs. If you opt for electronic retention, though, bear in mind USCIS permits this under certain conditions such as system checks preventing unauthorized alterations/deletions of records alongside maintaining an audit trail detailing changes made since creation.

A recommended practice is grouping all forms together within one file separate from other personnel files making them easily accessible during inspections while ensuring privacy standards are upheld. Remember not just current employees' documentation needs safeguarding; also remember former staff whose tenure falls within the stipulated time frames.

Maintain Compliance Through Proper Storage Practice

To ensure compliance throughout your Form I-9 process, create alert systems notifying impending expiration dates.

Key Takeaway:

Master the I-9 form maze by understanding retention rules, safeguarding completed forms, and maintaining compliance through proper storage practices. Remember to keep these documents for at least three years post-hiring or one year after termination - whichever comes later.

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Completing an I-9 Form

The I-9 form process is a crucial step in the hiring journey, yet it's often riddled with errors. Let's look into these typical blunders and discover how to stay away from them.

Filling Inaccurate or Partial Information

A recurring issue we see involves inaccurate or incomplete information on the form. For instance, not having Section 1 filled out by the employee before their first day of work can result in non-compliance issues. Similarly, employers who don't complete their section (Section 2) within three days after employment begins also fall into error territory.

Mishandling Document Verification

An integral part of making I-9 forms revolves around examining documents for verification purposes. Some employers overlook this critical stage when they fail to examine Form I-9 documentation properly - leading down a path towards potential compliance complications later on. 

Remember: original documents must be verified personally unless you're using an authorized representative or following remote procedures for your Form I-9 verifications.

Poor Record Keeping Practices

Record keeping is another area where slip-ups occur frequently - once that person's Form I-9 has been completed, retaining those records becomes essential as per federal guidelines which dictate holding onto these files either three years post-hire date OR one year after termination, whichever comes last.

Inadequate Use Of Updated Forms

  • Catching Up With The Latest Version

We cannot stress enough about staying updated with newer versions available at all times because relying solely upon older forms may lead you straight into troubled waters if caught during audits and inspections.

Decoding E-Verify and Its Relation to the I-9 Form

Eager to understand how E-Verify complements your Form I-9 process? It's simpler than you think. This web-based system is a handy tool that assists employers in confirming an employee's eligibility for employment within the United States.

The Interplay Between E-Verify and Your Completed Forms

The relationship between Form I-9 and E-Verify is one of verification, as both are used to confirm an individual's identity and eligibility for employment in the United States. Completing a person's Form I-9 involves verifying their identity along with work authorization, collecting information on citizenship status like whether they are a lawful permanent resident or hold other types of employment authorization.

This same set of details forms the basis when conducting verifications electronically through E-Verify. In essence, this service offers another layer of assurance beyond what physical examination can provide while examining an employee's Form I-9 documentation.

Advantages Galore: Why Using Both Is A Win-Win Situation

  • An enhanced level of confidence as fraudulent documents which might escape detection during manual checks can be identified easily via electronic cross-referencing using E-Verify.
  • A bonus feature offered by this service comes into play especially under current global circumstances where remote working has become commonplace - Remote Form I-9 Verification Process. With flexibility being key, such alternative procedures make life easier both for employees as well as employers alike.


You've cracked the code on the I-9 form. You now understand its importance in hiring and compliance. The document verification requirements are no longer Greek to you. Your storage system for these forms is now foolproof and audit-ready. Mistakes? Not on your watch! Your I-9 process is error-free! And E-Verify? It's an additional part of your overall strategy. But remember, there's more to HR than just paperwork.

There's hiring strategy, retention efforts, effective onboarding - all crucial aspects of building a successful team. If you're ready to dive deeper into these topics.

Subscribe to our newsletter