How this Five Guys franchise group reduced turnover from 150% to 42%
Brian Charyn is Executive Director of Operations at Sheridan Investments, a Five Guys franchisee group with 18 locations across New Jersey and Florida. Sheridan Investments adopted Workstream in November 2020. When the company acquired seven new stores in the St. Pete and Clearwater area in early 2026, Workstream was the first platform deployed.
“Workstream plus creating a great culture, our franchise was recognized for how low our New Jersey turnover was. We got it down into the 40s.”
Brian Charyn
The problem
A week to fill a role, turnover over 150%, and paper onboarding
About Five Guys
Five Guys is a well-known American fast-food chain famous for its made-to-order burgers, fresh-cut fries, and no-frills, ingredient-first approach. Founded in 1986, it has grown into a major player in the fast-casual burger space, with locations across the United States and internationally.
Locations: ~1,500
Industry: Restaurants
Before Workstream, Sheridan Investments relied on Talent Reef and Indeed. Talent Reef was tied into the Five Guys website application flow but, as Brian put it, “wasn’t keeping up with the times.” Job postings were duplicating without anyone cleaning them up, and communication went through the platform rather than direct text or email, which meant reaching a candidate required waiting for a callback.
Filling an open position took “about a week,” and turnover was at industry standard — over 100 percent, often closer to 140 to 150 percent. Without visibility into how many applications each store was receiving or whether GMs were reviewing them, Brian had no easy way to hold managers accountable. The result was that managers hired whoever walked through the door because they felt they had no other choice.
Onboarding was paper-based and inconsistent across locations.
What we've solved
Faster first contact, more applicants, and consistent onboarding
Sheridan Investments replaced Talent Reef with Workstream across all 18 locations, gaining real-time candidate messaging, a bigger applicant pool, direct manager accountability, and standardized electronic onboarding.
Real-time messaging
“The real-time texting and emailing was probably the most exciting part about it,” Brian says. A candidate who just applied could get a text before leaving a competing interview. Speed of first contact changed which candidates Sheridan Investments could win.
Application volume and manager accountability
Workstream generated significantly more applicants than the prior setup. “When you have a lot of applications, you feel as if you could say no to someone,” Brian says. “That’s pretty powerful.” It also gave Brian direct visibility into GM behavior: “All it takes is logging in and within 10 seconds I could see a store has 50 applications they haven’t looked at. GMs knowing that we know how many they’re getting is powerful also.”
Electronic onboarding
I-9s, W-2s, and the employee handbook with digital signatures are all handled through Workstream, standardizing the process across every location. “I know I can fly to Florida tomorrow and see an orientation in Naples and know it’s going to look the same as the one in New Jersey,” Brian says.
Fast acquisition onboarding
When Sheridan took over seven stores in the Clearwater market — locations that had operated without standardized hiring processes for 18 years — they were on Workstream within a week.
72%
reduction in turnover, from 150% to 42%
43%
reduction in time to hire, from 1 week to 4 days
THE RESULTS
Time-to-hire cut to four days, turnover down to 42.5%
- Time-to-hire: from roughly one week to about four days. Some hires happen the same day, when managers text a candidate immediately after they apply.
- Turnover: from 140–150% down to 42.5%. Brian calculated it from his own termination data — 17 employees per store across 18 locations is 306 staff; five terminations every two weeks is 130 a year. “That’s 42 and a half percent turnover,” he says. Five Guys recognized Sheridan Investments for the improvement in New Jersey.
- Consistent onboarding across all 18 locations, including newly acquired markets.
- Clearwater market fully onboarded in one week — seven stores that had run without standardized hiring processes for 18 years.
- Better applicant selectivity through volume: managers moved from hiring out of desperation to hiring out of choice.